A Fifth-Generation Baker Built the Hamptons’ Most Beloved French Bistro

If you spot the cornflower-blue Citroën 2CV parked along Main Street, you’ve found it. That vintage French deux chevaux belongs to Pierre Weber, and it signals you’ve arrived at the Hamptons’ most reliably romantic table. For over two decades, Pierre’s Bridgehampton has served as the East End’s living room, a place where presidents have dined, Bastille Day becomes a village-wide celebration, and the lobster fricassée flambéed tableside with cognac has launched a thousand marriage proposals.

However, when Weber first walked into an empty storefront here in 2002, nothing was guaranteed. Not a single customer showed up on opening weekend. That humbling start taught him something essential: in the Hamptons, you earn your place one bonjour at a time.

The Origin Story of Pierre’s Bridgehampton

Five Generations of French Flour

Pierre Weber’s culinary lineage stretches back to the 1820s in Alsace, where his family began baking in a France still recovering from Napoleon. Consequently, when Weber grew up in Paris’s 16th arrondissement, the patisserie wasn’t just a profession—it was destiny. His family’s shop, Weber’s Patisserie, taught him that bread must be perfect today and even better tomorrow.

“One of the worst things is certitude, leaving no room for doubt,” Weber once explained. This Alsatian philosophy—demanding excellence while embracing impermanence—would later define his Hamptons venture. Moreover, it gave him the resilience to survive what came next.

The New York Detour

Weber first came to America to run the New York City Marathon. He never went back. Instead, he launched Food Attitude, a wholesale pastry company supplying Manhattan’s most demanding clients. For eighteen years, he delivered croissants and tarts to Dean & DeLuca, luxury hotels, and country clubs throughout the city.

It was exhausting, anonymous work. Then one day, driving east, he heard about a restaurant for sale in Bridgehampton. “I thought, ‘Yeah, why not?'” Weber later recalled. That casual gamble would transform him from behind-the-scenes supplier to the face of Hamptons hospitality.

The July Fourth Silence

Pierre’s Bridgehampton opened over Fourth of July weekend, 2002. Weber expected fireworks. He got silence. Not a single customer walked through the door. Meanwhile, his savings dwindled with each empty hour.

“I discovered at that time that nothing is for granted,” Weber has said. “It was a very humbling experience.” Rather than panic, he doubled down on hospitality. Subsequently, he made a decision that would distinguish Pierre’s from every seasonal competitor: he would stay open 365 days a year, greeting every guest personally. Eventually, word spread. The locals came first. Then the summer crowd followed.

The Transformation Into a Hamptons Icon

The St. Barth’s Vision

Weber wanted Pierre’s Bridgehampton to feel like the Caribbean meets the Côte d’Azur. “Casual, yet elegant—like St. Barth’s,” he explained to 27 East. The sailboats painted on the windows weren’t decorative accidents. In fact, he chose those joyful primary colors specifically because they captured the Hamptons’ essence—water, sky, possibility.

Inside, white walls and burgundy accents created an airy intimacy. Round windows framed the passing traffic on Route 27 like a slow-motion film. Additionally, green fronds softened the mahogany bar where regulars still claim their spots. The effect was transportive, yet familiar.

The Market Expansion

By 2010, Pierre’s Bridgehampton had outgrown its original footprint. Consequently, Weber opened Pierre’s Gourmet Market next door, fulfilling a childhood dream. Here, his Alsatian pastry heritage found full expression: croissants, napoleons, meringues, and the bûche de Noël that earned a feature on Food Network’s The Best Thing I Ever Ate.

Celebrity chef Rocco DiSpirito called Pierre’s holiday Yule log essential viewing—and essential eating. Furthermore, the market’s homemade ice cream and Illy coffee became their own summer rituals. For a time, Weber even expanded to a second location in the historic Sagaponack General Store, though staffing challenges eventually brought him back to his Bridgehampton home base.

Presidential Status

Pierre’s Bridgehampton has hosted its share of boldface names. Most notably, the Clintons have dined here, establishing the restaurant as presidential-approved territory. However, Weber doesn’t chase celebrity. Instead, he treats every guest with the same infectious enthusiasm.

“Sometimes I feel I am in charge of a theater,” he told Dan’s Papers. Indeed, his staff know their lines by heart. The lights warm just so. A fern gets adjusted here, a sauce sampled there. Consequently, first-timers and regulars alike feel seen—not just served, but embraced.

What Makes Pierre’s Bridgehampton Iconic

The Lobster Fricassée

Ask regulars what to order, and they’ll answer before you finish the question: the fricassée de homard du Maine. This two-pound Maine lobster arrives flambéed tableside with cognac and tarragon, accompanied by perfectly golden pommes frites. It’s Wednesday’s plat du jour, when the price drops, but it’s worth full freight any night.

Weber first served this dish at a small village restaurant in France. When he opened Pierre’s Bridgehampton, he knew it had to anchor the menu. Subsequently, it became his signature—coastal French technique meeting Long Island’s legendary lobster waters.

Bastille Day

Every July, Pierre’s transforms into a French village square. Accordion musicians serenade the terrace. Champagne flows during daylong tastings. Meanwhile, staff dress as kings, queens, and gendarmes. It’s theatrical, excessive, and entirely sincere.

For Weber, Bastille Day isn’t just marketing. It’s homecoming. Additionally, it demonstrates what distinguishes Pierre’s from competitors: this restaurant celebrates French culture without taking itself too seriously. The flags—French tricolor flanking Stars and Stripes—flutter from the sidewalk tables like yacht sails freed from their windows.

The Deux Chevaux

That cornflower-blue Citroën 2CV parked outside? It’s not a prop. Weber actually drives it. The vintage French car has become as iconic as the restaurant itself—a visual shorthand announcing “Pierre is here.”

The 2CV, produced from 1948 to 1990, was designed to carry French farmers and their eggs across plowed fields without breakage. Similarly, Pierre’s carries Hamptons visitors through brunches, anniversaries, and countless sunset cocktails without losing its essential character. Both endure through stubborn charm.

Experience Pierre’s Bridgehampton Today

What to Order

Beyond the lobster fricassée, insiders recommend the bouillabaisse Marseillaise—a broth perfumed with Pastis and saffron cradling mussels, clams, scallops, and cod. Furthermore, the Alsatian onion tart offers a thin-crust connection to Weber’s heritage. For brunch, the Oeufs en Meurette—poached eggs with caramelized onions, bacon, and veal stock on toasted brioche—demonstrates why fifth-generation bakers shouldn’t make omelets like everyone else.

At the market, Rocco DiSpirito wasn’t wrong about that bûche de Noël. However, summer means homemade ice cream and croissants that rival anything in Paris. Additionally, the fresh juices and smoothies have sustained beachgoers since 2002.

When to Go

Pierre’s Bridgehampton opens at 8 AM for breakfast and doesn’t close until 10 PM weeknights, 11 PM weekends. Consequently, you can build an entire day around it. Start with café au lait and brioche. Return for a long lunch of French onion soup before antiquing. Then claim a terrace table at golden hour.

“Sit on the terrace at golden hour,” Weber advises in Modern Luxury. “There’s something about the light in Bridgehampton in the early evening—it’s soft and cinematic.” Indeed, the permit for outdoor dining arrived in 2010 and transformed the Main Street experience entirely.

The Insider Move

The Insider’s Take: Wednesday’s lobster fricassée special saves you $12 off the regular price. Moreover, the prix fixe menu—two courses for a set price—runs all night Sundays and Thursdays, plus before 6:30 PM on weekends. Additionally, the late bar scene draws a sophisticated crowd. Order a glass of Alsatian Riesling at the mahogany bar and let the theater unfold around you.

The Legacy of Pierre’s Bridgehampton

The 365-Day Philosophy

What separates Pierre’s Bridgehampton from seasonal competitors is stubborn consistency. While other restaurants shutter after Labor Day, Weber stays open every single day. “I love the ocean and I love the quality of life here,” he says. “I love what I do.”

This commitment attracts year-round locals—shopkeepers, real estate agents, the people who keep the Hamptons running when the hedge-funders retreat to Manhattan. Consequently, Pierre’s functions as genuine community hub, not just summer destination. Families return for anniversaries. Friendships form over oysters and Champagne. Meanwhile, Weber remembers faces and asks about grandchildren.

Why It Endures

“People come back because they feel remembered,” Weber explains. “They have memories here—meals that marked anniversaries and friendships made over oysters and Champagne. Our job is to make sure that when they return, the magic is still there.”

That magic isn’t just food—it’s feeling. Pierre’s Bridgehampton has survived 23 years, a pandemic, staffing crises, and countless trendier competitors because Weber understood something fundamental. In the Hamptons, everyone wants to belong somewhere. Furthermore, belonging requires someone who notices when you walk in.

The cornflower-blue Citroën will be parked outside. Pierre will be bonjouring guests. And another summer will pass into memory at the most consistently romantic table on the East End. Some things, thankfully, don’t need to change.

Continue Your Hamptons Journey

Related Articles