The 4 PM Pizza Hunt: A Southampton Confession

Finding the Best Pizza in the Hamptons

Look, I’m not going to bullshit you. It was 4 PM on a Tuesday, and I’d just done the most mundane thing a human being can do in Southampton—dropped a package at the post office. Not a vintage Hermès trunk being shipped to my pied-à-terre in Paris. Not rare truffles expedited to Daniel Boulud. A package. At the post office.

My stomach was making that prehistoric growl that says: “Feed me now or I’m shutting down non-essential systems.” You know the feeling. That moment when hunger crosses the line from polite suggestion to hostile takeover.

So there I was, sitting in my car like some common tourist, iPhone in hand, fingers already typing those four pathetic words into the search bar: “best pizza near me.”

Let me tell you something about that phrase. “Best pizza near me” is the white flag of culinary surrender. It’s what you type when you’ve abandoned all pretense of sophistication, when the carefully curated persona you’ve built—the one that knows which vineyard produces the superior Montrachet, the one that can spot a fake Patek Philippe from fifty yards—crumbles in the face of base, primal need.

But here’s the thing about Southampton at 4 PM on a weekday: it’s that magic hour between the ladies-who-lunch crowd and the dinner reservation set. The village goes quiet. The Range Rovers thin out. And in that brief window, you can almost pretend you’re not in one of the most expensive zip codes in America, hunting for the best pizza delivery or best pizza restaurants like some college kid stumbling out of a bar at 2 AM.

The Complete Hamptons Pizza Guide: Best Pizza Places by Town

Whether you’re searching for “pizza near me,” “pizza delivery near me,” or the best New York style pizza in the Hamptons, this is your definitive guide to finding exceptional pizza across the East End.

SOUTHAMPTON – Best Pizza Southampton

La Parmigiana ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

48 NY-27A, Southampton

Since 1974, this family-owned institution serves authentic New York/Brooklyn style pizza with thick crust, generous sauce, and melted cheese. Their broccoli rabe pizza features sweet Italian sausage, garlic, and homemade mozzarella. Known for generous portions and unpretentious atmosphere.

Visit La Parmigiana →

P&G Pizza & Deli ⭐⭐⭐⭐½

Southampton Village

Unassuming, reliable, and consistently delicious. A neighborhood favorite for classic New York style pizza and Italian deli offerings.

Pellegrino’s Pizza Bar & Restaurant ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

1271 Noyack Road, Southampton

Features both NY-style and authentic Italian pizza from super-hot ovens. All dough made in-house using a 20-year-old wild yeast starter. The spicy Diavola Pie with piquant peppers is a cult favorite.

Visit Pellegrino’s →

Melrose East Restaurant & Pizza ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Southampton

From cheese pizza to cauliflower pizza, offers the best New York-style pizza with quick, reliable delivery. Dine-in, takeout, and no-contact delivery available.

Paul’s Italian American Restaurant ⭐⭐⭐⭐½

Southampton

Best Neapolitan pizza in Southampton with authentic Italian preparation and atmosphere.

WESTHAMPTON BEACH – Best Pizza Westhampton

Brunetti Pizza Wine Bar ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

61 Main St., Westhampton Beach | 631-288-3003

Everything made from scratch: breads, oils, limoncello, dough, and mozzarella. Pizza menu includes suggested wine pairings. The vegan pie pairs perfectly with fruit-forward Primitivo.

Visit Brunetti Pizza →

Tonino’s Pizza ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Westhampton Beach

Great for casual slices or full pies. Loved for generous toppings and quick service.

HAMPTON BAYS – Best Pizza Hampton Bays

Uncle Joe’s Ristorante ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

258 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays

Two distinct dining rooms—one upscale for fine dining, one casual for beach-goers. Try their white pizza topped with spinach or broccoli. Full Italian restaurant with exceptional service.

Visit Uncle Joe’s →

Francesca’s Restaurant & Pizzeria ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Hampton Bays

Reliable neighborhood favorite with wide menu including soups, salads, burgers, pasta, and specialty pizzas. Great for families and large orders. Also serves ice cream.

Scotto’s Pork Store ⭐⭐⭐⭐½

25 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays

Top-rated authentic Italian pork store with exceptional pizza menu. Try their brick oven stuffed pizza with sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella, spinach, and ricotta. Also offers catering.

BRIDGEHAMPTON – Best Pizza Bridgehampton

World Pie ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

2402 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton

Kitchen open until midnight every night. Known for unique smoked pizza featuring smoked mozzarella, tomato, and basil. “Gourmet pizza” destination.

Visit World Pie →

Armin & Judy ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Route 27, Bridgehampton

Famous for their “I Baguette You” sign. The focaccia-style pizza is a standout, along with salads, vegetables, and other creative entrees.

SAG HARBOR – Best Pizza Sag Harbor

Sag Pizza ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

103 Main Street, Sag Harbor | 631-725-3167

Chef Laurent Tourondel’s Neapolitan-style pizzeria capturing Amalfi Coast essence. Wood-fired pizzas with San Marzano tomatoes and premium mozzarella. Great wine selection, outdoor seating with village views. Ships pizza kits nationally via Goldbelly.

Visit Sag Pizza →

Pizza Pizza ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Inside Cluckman’s, Sag Harbor

New addition offering excellent regular slices with delicious sauce and cheese. White cheese pizza with mushrooms is a favorite. Finally, a place for a proper slice in Sag Harbor.

Cappelletti ⭐⭐⭐⭐½

3284 Noyac Road, Sag Harbor

Excellent pizza to-go with extensive menu. All ingredients fresh, including homemade meatballs. Seasonal local ingredients.

Espresso Da Asporto ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Sag Harbor

Italian hole-in-the-wall famous for sandwiches, but their pizza slices are legendary—enormous portions (equivalent to three normal slices) served in pizza boxes for under $4.

Lulu Kitchen & Bar ⭐⭐⭐⭐

126 Main St., Sag Harbor | 631-725-0900

Mediterranean hot spot with all dough and sauces made in-house. Wood-burning grill reaches 800°F and cooks pizzas in three minutes. The Trafata with truffle paste is luxurious.

EAST HAMPTON – Best Pizza East Hampton

Sam’s Restaurant ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

36 Newtown Lane, East Hampton

Serving since 1947. Local tavern theme with delicious thin-crust pizzas and red sauce pasta. Extensive list of meat and topping options plus gourmet pies. Sam’s Special features sausage, onions, garlic, peppers, and mushrooms.

Visit Sam’s Restaurant →

Fierro’s Pizza ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

East Hampton Village

East Hampton’s village pizzeria for almost 40 years. Fresh ingredients, daily-made dough. Now offers ice cream, health-conscious entrees, and catering for groups of 6, 12, and 20. Online ordering and delivery available. Open year-round.

Visit Fierro’s Pizza →

Little Charli ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

East Hampton

NYC favorite since 2004, expanded to Hamptons. Wood-fired pizzas with soppressata, spicy honey, truffle, burrata, and shallot. Open until 11 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

Moby’s ⭐⭐⭐⭐½

341 Pantigo Road, East Hampton

Seasonal (late May-November). Charmingly restored 1880s home serving coastal Italian food. Seasonally driven pizzas with local ingredients like summer squash with whipped ricotta or funghi with wild mushrooms and fonduta.

Visit Moby’s →

Cittanuova ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

East Hampton Village

Open 7 days until 11 PM. International-style pizzas with thin crispy crust, wonderful sauce and cheese. Beloved by locals and celebrities alike.

Nick & Toni’s ⭐⭐⭐⭐

East Hampton

Italian restaurant with excellent brick oven pizza. Celebrity hotspot—easier reservations in off-season.

La Capanina ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Montauk Highway, East Hampton

The Hamptons’ most iconic pizza place. Classic New York style with amazing crust. Sounds and smells transport you to NYC. Perfect for pickup on your way from the city.

Pepperoni’s Pizza ⭐⭐⭐⭐

East Hampton

Handcrafted full Italian menu with indoor and outdoor seating. Delivery available within 5 miles ($50 minimum, $7.50-$10 delivery fee).

Visit Pepperoni’s Pizza →

AMAGANSETT – Best Pizza Amagansett

Fini Pizza ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Main Street, Amagansett (former Astro’s Pizza location)

Brooklyn favorite brought to the Hamptons. Thin crust perfection. The White Cheese pie with lemon zest and hot honey is exceptional. Pricier ($39 for pie) but worth it. Classic NYC slice shop experience.

Visit Fini Pizza →

Best Pizza & Dive Bar ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

2095 Montauk Highway, Amagansett | 631-668-8378

Thursday-Friday 3-10 PM, Saturday-Sunday noon-10 PM. Lives up to its name. Fresh garlic knots, excellent meatballs in chunky tomato sauce, and quality pizzas. Also serves Buffalo wings.

MONTAUK – Best Pizza Montauk

Roberta’s ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Montauk

Neapolitan-style pizzas with top-notch mozzarella and on-site-cured meats. The “Bee Sting” (tomatoes, mozzarella, soppressata, basil, chili, honey) is the crowd favorite. “Marissa Tomeito” and “White Guy” also beloved.

Fierro’s Pizza – Montauk ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Same parking lot as Montauk Brewing Company

East Hampton classic’s new Montauk outpost. Classic NY style pizza takeout with picnic benches for outdoor seating. Full Italian dinners available.

Visit Fierro’s Montauk →

Alimentari Beach ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Center of Montauk, across from The Green

Developed by L’industrie’s Massimo Laveglia and Nicholas Baglivo. Personal-size thin crust pizzas (burrata, pepperoni, tartufo, clam, veggie). Fig and guanciale offers perfect savory-sweet balance. Open 8 AM with espresso bar. Breakfast pie available.

Harvest on Fort Pond ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

11 S. Emery St., Montauk | 631-668-5574

White tablecloth dining with elevated pizza menu. Bacon jalapeño pizza is exceptional. Also offers traditional tomato and mozzarella, plus sausage, broccoli, and gorgonzola.

Pizza Village ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Montauk

Late-night legend serving hot cheese pizza from the window until 2 AM. Perfect for post-bar cravings.

Il Forno ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Montauk Yacht Club, Lake Montauk

Only pizza in Montauk with water views. Wood-fired pizzas at the cafe next to outdoor pool or at the bar. Outstanding Caesar salad.

SPRINGS – Best Pizza Springs

Springs Pizza ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Springs

Hidden gem with loyal following. Open year-round. Try the white pie! Also offers great salads and wings. Pick up a 4-pack of Lazy Lightning IPA by Springs Brewery for perfect pairing.

SHELTER ISLAND – Best Pizza Shelter Island

Isola ⭐⭐⭐⭐

15 Grand Ave., Shelter Island Heights | 631-749-9036

Eye-catching white and blue trim with inviting front porch. Shelter Island’s first wood-fired pizza option since opening in 2017.

Why “Best Pizza Near Me” Matters in the Hamptons

The phrase “best pizza near me” isn’t just a search term—it’s a lifeline. When you’re navigating the Hamptons, whether you’re a local or visiting for the weekend, knowing where to find quality pizza delivery, the best pizza restaurants, or just a damn good slice makes all the difference.

These aren’t just pizza places. They’re institutions. From Southampton pizza traditions to Montauk pizza innovation, from Sag Harbor’s refined pies to East Hampton’s decades-old favorites, each spot offers something unique.

The best New York style pizza can be found across the East End, whether you’re craving thin crust perfection at Fini Pizza in Amagansett, thick Sicilian slices at Hampton Kitchen/Deli, or wood-fired Neapolitan excellence at Sag Pizza. Pizza delivery near me searches lead to reliable spots like Melrose East in Southampton or Francesca’s in Hampton Bays, while late-night cravings are solved by Pizza Village in Montauk.

The Moral of the Story

Strip away the pretense, and you’ll find that the best decisions aren’t made with algorithms or crowdsourced opinions. They’re made in that raw, honest space where hunger meets instinct, where you stop performing and start being real.

Sometimes the most luxurious thing you can do is exactly what you want, exactly when you want it—whether that’s a $39 artisanal pie from Fini or a $4 monster slice from Espresso’s in Sag Harbor.

The Hamptons pizza scene proves that excellence exists at every price point, in every town, for every craving. You just have to know where to look.

Now get out there and find your slice.