Where to Stay in Southampton: Hotels, Inns, and the Art of Choosing Your Base Camp

Your Hotel Is Your First Sentence

In a village where your restaurant reservation declares your social fluency and your street address communicates your net worth, the hotel you choose on your first Southampton weekend introduces you before you have spoken a word. Naturally, the 1708 House says you value history and intimacy. Meanwhile, the Southampton Inn says you value convenience and flexibility. And the Capri says you value scene and style. None of these is wrong. All of them are legible to anyone who has spent a summer here.

Southampton’s hotel inventory is small by design. This is not a resort town. Rather, it is a residential village that tolerates visitors. Year-round population is roughly 4,000. In summer, that number swells to five or six times as many, but the swelling happens in rental houses, shared estates, and guest rooms at friends’ properties, not in hotel lobbies. Altogether, the number of hotel rooms within walking distance of Main Street can be counted in the low hundreds.

Book early, book now, and book before you buy your beach parking pass.

She calls the 1708 House in February for a July weekend. The woman on the phone says “Which weekend in July?” with a tone that implies the answer may determine the outcome. She names the Polo Hamptons weekend (July 18). The woman pauses. “I can offer you Tuesday through Thursday.” She takes it. She will learn, over the next four months, that the Thursday arrival is the correct one anyway.

The Properties: Ranked by Character

The 1708 House

126 Main Street, Southampton. 631-287-1708. 1708house.com.
Type: Historic bed and breakfast. Rooms: 15. Open: Year-round.
Price range: $250 to $600+ per night (seasonal).
Walk to Cooper’s Beach: 7 minutes. Walk to Sant Ambroeus: 2 minutes.

The 1708 House is the lodging choice that requires no explanation and rewards extended attention. Indeed, the house was known to exist in 1708 (the name is literal, not aspirational), and its museum-quality cellar dates to approximately 1648.

An extensive restoration commenced in 1993, and the inn opened to guests in 1996. Fifteen guestrooms feature exposed wooden beams, clawfoot tubs, four-poster beds, and antique furnishings.

Location is the 1708 House’s definitive advantage. At 126 Main Street, you are in the village. Not near the village. In it. Sant Ambroeus is two minutes on foot. Cooper’s Beach takes seven. And the Southampton Arts Center is just three minutes away. In other words, you do not need a car or the Jitney. You need only a pair of shoes and the inclination to use them.

Best for: History enthusiasts. Couples. The reader who chose Southampton over East Hampton because they value understatement. Anyone who wants to sleep in a building that predates the American Revolution by seven decades.

Book if: You are visiting for the first time and want the most authentically Southampton experience available without knowing anyone who lives here.

Southampton Inn

91 Hill Street, Southampton. 631-283-6500. southamptoninn.com.
Type: Full-service hotel. Rooms: 90. Open: Year-round.
Price range: $243 to $800+ per night (seasonal).
Walk to Cooper’s Beach: 12 minutes. Walk to Main Street: 5 minutes.

The Southampton Inn is the largest lodging property in the village and the one that most closely approximates what the rest of America considers a hotel. Ninety rooms (bright, airy, contemporary) span a property that includes a swimming pool, games room, lawn games, tennis court, and Claude’s restaurant. Essentially, this scale allows for what the B&Bs cannot: group bookings, family accommodations with connecting rooms, and the anonymity that comes with being one of ninety guests rather than one of fifteen.

On Hill Street, you are five minutes from Main Street on foot and twelve minutes from Cooper’s Beach. Moreover, the property’s grounds are large enough to feel like a small resort.

Best for: Families. Groups. Extended stays. Business travelers attending the U.S. Open who need reliable amenities and proximity without intimacy. Anyone who wants a pool without buying a house.

Book if: You are bringing children, need multiple rooms, or want the flexibility of a full-service property. The Southampton Inn is also the most reliable year-round option, making it the choice for off-season visits when smaller properties may close or reduce service.

Capri Southampton

281 County Road 39A, Southampton. caprisouthampton.com.
Type: Boutique hotel. Rooms: 13. Open: Seasonal (approximately May through October).
Price range: $877 to $1,500+ per night (peak season).
Walk to Main Street: 15 minutes. Drive to Cooper’s Beach: 5 minutes.

The Capri is the boutique play. Essentially, thirteen rooms in a Tudor-style property with a pool scene that functions as a social venue independent of the rooms themselves. The Capri has cycled through several dining concepts over the years. In each case, the concept reflected the hotel’s ambition to be more than a place to sleep.

For summer 2026, the headline is Maison Close. The Parisian-inspired restaurant and nightlife concept, which built its reputation at the SoHo flagship and a previous Montauk outpost, opens at the Capri in June. Chef Geoffrey Lechantoux blends classic French techniques with seasonal, locally sourced, organic ingredients. The concept merges Riviera aesthetics with what the hospitality press calls “celebratory dining culture,” which means the line between dinner and entertainment dissolves somewhere around the second cocktail. Maison Close will also oversee food and beverage operations for the pool, expanding the Capri’s social footprint beyond the dining room.

Indeed, this is a significant addition to the Southampton dining and nightlife landscape. The Capri with Maison Close becomes, potentially, the first property in the village that functions simultaneously as hotel, restaurant, pool club, and late-night destination.

Best for: The brand executive scouting the East End. Couples who want boutique intimacy with social energy. Anyone who recognizes the Maison Close name from SoHo and wants to see it translated to the Hamptons.

Book if: You prioritize scene over square footage and are willing to pay the premium that thirteen rooms and a Parisian restaurant command.

The Bentley Hotel Southampton

161 Hills Station Road, Southampton.
Type: Art Deco boutique hotel. Open: Seasonal.
Price range: $350 to $700+ per night (seasonal).

Notably, the Bentley occupies a niche between the intimacy of the 1708 House and the scale of the Southampton Inn. The Art Deco aesthetic, seasonal outdoor pool, beach bar, and nearby private beach access create a property that reviews consistently describe as “exceptional” (9.6 out of 10 on major booking platforms). Suites with full kitchenettes accommodate longer stays. The smoke-free property offers laundry facilities and twenty-four-hour front desk service.

Best for: Couples and small families seeking boutique character with more amenities than a B&B. The pool and beach bar add a resort dimension that the village-center properties do not provide.

The Atlantic

1655 County Road 39, Southampton.
Type: Motel-style, renovated. Price range: From $124 per night.

The Atlantic represents the accessible end of the Southampton lodging spectrum. Specifically, renovated rooms at rates that begin where the Capri’s rates end. The location on County Road 39 is not walkable to the village center (you will need a car or a ride), but the price point makes it the option for visitors who want to be based in Southampton without spending the equivalent of a monthly car payment per night.

Best for: Budget-conscious visitors. Solo travelers. Anyone attending the U.S. Open who needs a bed and a shower and intends to spend every waking hour at Shinnecock Hills.

The Rental Alternative

Why Most Visitors Don’t Stay in Hotels

In reality, the majority of Southampton’s summer visitors do not stay in hotels. They rent houses. The rental market operates on a tier system that mirrors the purchase market:

South of the highway rentals ($10,000 to $50,000+ per week): Estate section houses with pools, hedgerows, and the full Southampton residential experience. Generally, these book by January for peak summer weeks. The best properties book the previous fall.

Village proper rentals ($5,000 to $15,000 per week): Walkable to Main Street and the beach. Smaller properties. Still, charming enough to photograph for Instagram. Functional enough to host a dinner party.

North of the highway rentals ($2,000 to $5,000 per week): Comparatively, more space for less money. Less prestige. More parking. The practical choice for families who care about bedrooms, not hedgerows.

Share houses ($1,500 to $5,000 per share, seasonal): Typically, this is the entry-level Hamptons experience. Typically eight to twelve people splitting a house from Memorial Day through Labor Day, with rotating weekends. The social dynamics of a share house are either the best part of the experience or the worst, depending entirely on who else is in the house.

Rental platforms include Hamptons-specific agencies (Saunders, Corcoran, Compass, Douglas Elliman) alongside Airbnb, VRBO, and direct owner listings. However, for properties above $10,000 per week, the brokerage relationship matters.

The Timing Guide

When to Book

U.S. Open week (June 15 to 21, 2026): If you have not booked by now, your options are limited. Essentially, you are looking at properties with cancellations, the Atlantic, or staying in Riverhead (thirty minutes west). The U.S. Open brings 150,000 visitors. The hotel inventory holds fewer than 200 rooms in the village. The math is unforgiving.

Fourth of July weekend: Book by March. Cancel by May if plans change (check cancellation policies).

Polo Hamptons weekends (July 18 and 25): Book by April. In particular, the Polo Hamptons guest list overlaps heavily with the kind of visitor who books the 1708 House and the Capri.

August: Overall, the most competitive month. Every weekend is difficult. Midweek availability persists through most of the season.

September: Of course, this is the secret. Dr. Beach recommends September for Cooper’s Beach (fewer crowds, warm water). Hotels drop rates. The village exhales. The visitors who come in September understand something the July crowd does not.

Rate Expectations

Generally, peak season rates (July and August weekends) run two to four times higher than shoulder season rates (June weekdays, September). The 1708 House in July might cost $500 per night. In October, $250. The Capri in August might cost $1,200 per night. In May, $600. Consequently, the gap is significant enough to shift a trip by two weeks if your calendar allows it.

The Decision Framework

Where the Conversation Continues

For over twenty-three years, Social Life Magazine has covered the East End’s hospitality landscape.

For a full overview, the Southampton Village Dossier is the definitive guide to the village these hotels serve. Similarly, the 72 Hours in Southampton itinerary maps the optimal weekend from any of the properties listed above.

If your hospitality brand, hotel, inn, or rental property serves the Southampton market, then Social Life Magazine’s paid feature program places your story in front of 25,000 copies per issue.

Polo Hamptons 2026 (July 18 and 25, 900 Lumber Lane, Bridgehampton) is the event that fills every hotel in this guide to capacity. Naturally, BMW North America sponsors. Christie Brinkley hosts. The cabana is where the guest who booked the 1708 House meets the guest who rented on Ox Pasture Road, and neither can tell the difference, which is either the democracy of polo or the genius of Southampton.

To receive Social Life Magazine delivered to your door (or to the door of whichever property you have booked for July), visit our subscription page.

Southampton has fewer than 200 hotel rooms within walking distance of Main Street. Since 1640, the village has been hosting visitors. Consequently, the ratio of demand to supply has never favored the latecomer. Book early. Arrive Thursday. Stay through Sunday. And understand that in Southampton, where you sleep is the prologue. What happens between the pillow and the beach is the story.