In a room full of real money, someone is always faking it. Here is how to spot the fake billionaire at a Manhattan private club, what New York learned from the most famous fake heiress of all, and why the real thing is usually much quieter.

Real money vs. fake money, at a glance

The tell Fake money Real money
The watch Brand-new, oversized, mentioned in conversation Old, scratched, never mentioned
The bill Grabs it loudly, then “has a card issue” Settles it quietly, often before you notice
The stories Big numbers, no details Small details, no numbers
The name-dropping Constant Rare, and usually about someone else’s success
The staff Ignored or bossed around Known by name
The plan Always about to close a huge deal Already closed it years ago, and would rather talk about you

For a while in the late 2010s, a young woman who called herself Anna Delvey moved through some of New York’s most expensive rooms, telling people she was a German heiress. She stayed in luxury hotels, picked up checks with borrowed confidence and pitched a private arts club, for which she sought a $22 million loan, according to NBC News.

None of it was real. In 2019, a Manhattan jury convicted Anna Sorokin, her real name, of grand larceny and theft of services, according to NBC News. Her story became a Netflix series, and a generation of New Yorkers learned something uncomfortable: the city’s most exclusive rooms are surprisingly easy to fool, at least for a while.

Every private club in Manhattan has had its own smaller version of that story. Here is how to tell the difference between someone who has money and someone who is wearing it.

How can you tell if someone is faking being rich?

People faking wealth tend to talk about money, show their possessions and make big promises with few details. People with real wealth tend to do the opposite: they rarely mention money, wear older things they actually like, and are specific about their work but vague about their net worth. The louder the display, the more likely it is a performance.

Think of it like a new restaurant versus an old one. The new one puts its awards in the window. The old one has been full every night for 30 years and has never bothered to hang a sign.

The watch is rented

The first tell is the watch, and not because it is too expensive. It is because it is mentioned. Someone who has worn the same watch for 20 years rarely brings it up. Someone who borrowed, rented or just bought it cannot help himself. Watch subscription and rental services exist in New York, and so do people who use them for one big night.

Real money tends to be boring about objects. The watch is scratched, the shoes have been resoled, the jacket is from a tailor who retired years ago. Ask the owner about any of it and you will get a shrug and a story about the tailor, not the price.

The table is comped, and the jet is a fraction

The second tell is the bill. The fake billionaire makes a show of picking up the check, then something goes wrong: the card is declined, the assistant will “sort it out tomorrow,” or a friend quietly pays. Anna Sorokin was convicted partly on theft of services, which, in plain terms, means not paying for things she had already enjoyed.

Travel stories work the same way. Someone who constantly mentions “my jet” may own a share in one, or may have flown on one once. Fractional ownership is a perfectly sensible way to fly, but it is a very different thing from owning the plane. Real owners of real planes mostly complain about the paperwork.

Big numbers, no details

The third tell is in the stories. Fake wealth speaks in round numbers: “a hundred-million-dollar deal,” “a billion-dollar fund,” “my family office.” Ask one follow-up question, such as who the other investors were or what the company actually makes, and the story gets vague very quickly.

Real wealth works the other way around. Successful people can talk for an hour about the boring details of how their business works, because they built it. What they rarely do is tell you what it is worth. If someone knows their net worth to the decimal point and none of their own customers’ names, be careful.

How do private clubs keep fakes out?

Private clubs keep fakes out mainly through sponsors and committees. Most selective Manhattan clubs require a current member to vouch for an applicant, and members are reluctant to risk their own standing on someone they barely know. That chain of trust is much harder to fake than a watch or a story.

It is not perfect. Guests can get in on a member’s invitation, and charm goes a long way at a bar. But the system works over time. A member who brings the same guest every week, and keeps getting stuck with the bill, eventually stops. Our story on why NYC clubs turn down millionaires explains how committees think, and our story on the art of the club sponsor shows why vouching matters so much.

Why do people fake it at all?

Most people who exaggerate their wealth are not criminals. They are nervous. They have walked into a room where everyone seems richer, and they are afraid of being found out as the one who does not belong. So they turn up the volume: a bigger watch, a bigger story, a bigger tip.

That is worth remembering before you judge too harshly. Nearly everyone in a Manhattan club has felt like an impostor at some point. The difference is what they do about it. Some perform. The smart ones ask questions, listen and let the room come to them. Our field guide to the people inside NYC’s clubs introduces the Fund Guy, who is usually not a fake at all, just a little too eager.

The real tell is kindness

After all the watches, jets and round numbers, the most reliable tell is how someone treats the people who cannot do anything for them. Fake wealth is always performing for an audience, so it saves its charm for the people who matter. Real confidence, the kind that comes from being comfortable with yourself, is the same with the bartender as it is with the billionaire.

That is also the good news. You do not need a rented watch to fit into any room in Manhattan. Be curious, be generous, pay your share and learn the names of the people who work there. That is the one look nobody can fake for long. For the bigger picture, read our guide to the velvet rope wars.

Frequently asked questions

Who was the fake heiress in New York?
Anna Sorokin, who called herself Anna Delvey, posed as a wealthy German heiress in New York in the late 2010s. In 2019, a Manhattan jury convicted her of grand larceny and theft of services, according to NBC News. Her story inspired the Netflix series Inventing Anna.

What are signs someone is pretending to be rich?
Common signs include constantly mentioning brands and prices, speaking about deals in big round numbers without details, making a show of paying and then having problems with the bill, and treating staff poorly. People with real wealth tend to be quieter about money.

Can people fake their way into private clubs?
Sometimes, for a while, especially as a member’s guest. Selective clubs rely on sponsors and committees, which makes it hard to become a full member without someone credible vouching for you. Over time, inconsistencies tend to surface.

Sources